I really think the p2p tax idea is a good one. I'm sure that far more people would sign up for this than for the music services that have appeared so far. That means it could also, very easily, be cheaper than these existing services and if the 'tax' income was sent to the **AA's they could actually stop moaning since they'd still be making a profit (let's face it, it only costs them a few cents to press a CD/DVD).
Perhaps we should start a campaign?
Going back to what Ecto said earlier about having to wait a hundred years or so for free access and the demise of p2p.... Well, I don't think p2p is actually ever going to go away. The nature of it will change for sure but as 'distributed computing' becomes more popular and as certain types of p2p clients such as
FolderShare which continuosly update files in the shared folders of all connected clients (so
all clients in the network have
all the latest copies of
all the files) develop further, I think what we're eventually going to see is .... a ubiquitous information network. All the info, all the files, all the knowledge and all the media that was ever digitised will be available everywhere, to everyone with the hardware needed to see it. This is what the Internet should become. Free and complete for all. Sounds like something you saw on Star Trek? I hope so. It is achievable.
And now, the rambling, Off-topic, extra information bit: CERN, the physics centre in Switzerland, are preparing to start their new collider (LHC - Large Hadron Collider) in 2007. In April of this year, as part of the testing of the computer infrastructure for the experiment, they sustained output of 600 MB per second of data which was streamed to 7 test sites in Europe and the US over the course of 10 days. The test was successful. To put that into perspective, the total amount of data transmitted (500 terabytes) would take an average domestic broadband connection about 250 years to download. Wireless networks recently got a boost (Siemens successfully tested throughput of 1 gigabit per second - average WiFi nets manage only 50 megabits) meaning that the huge outpouring of data that is now possible can be transmitted in acceptable timescales.... even where there are no cables.